More or Less · Topics · Episode #168

Amazon Blocks Muse, and Sam Explains Why a "Perfectly Efficient" Agent Economy Destroys Capitalism

Clip from the full recording, 33:25–40:42 · download mp4

Amazon shutting Meta's new agent Muse out of its marketplace kicks off a sprawling fight over agent commerce — bot blocking, open-source end-runs, subscription-killing agents, and Sam's theory that an economy run entirely by frictionless agents eventually has no profit left in it at all.

Jessica opens with fresh news: in week two of Meta’s Muse launch, Amazon has blocked it outright. Brit explains the likely reasons — Amazon has its own shopping agent to protect and a massive advertising business it doesn’t want disintermediated — while Dave argues blocking is pointless in the long run because open-source agents like OpenClaw run from a user’s own machine and can’t be blocked the way a hosted bot can; large platforms will instead end up negotiating case-by-case business-development deals, the same dynamic as AdWords-era arms treaties. Sam volunteers he’s already given Claude full control of a Mac Mini, calling the blocking fight a permanent ‘war of attrition’ as platforms try to detect programmatic behavior and agents are tuned to look more human.

The conversation widens into real-world consequences: Dave’s favorite story of the week is that the first thing everyone does with a new agent is have it mass-unsubscribe from email lists, prompting Jessica to joke that The Information’s subscriptions are up regardless. Brit already has her agent summarizing her inbox and wants to filter Amazon listings to American-only brands (Dave notes a Chrome extension already exists), which Jessica frames as more about Brit’s persistent ‘patriotism’ bit than practicality.

Sam closes the segment with the sharpest idea in it: his biggest issue with tools like Muse and Grok isn’t capability, it’s throughput — he’s spending roughly $2,000 a month on CPU (not GPU) because he wants not one fast computer but a huge number of slower, parallel ones to run his own projects, and he’d happily pay thousands more for that. He then connects the whole agent-commerce fight back to his liability thesis: Amazon obviously doesn’t want to become one of fifteen interchangeable services an agent price-shops in real time, because a perfectly efficient, frictionless agent economy with no brand loyalty or trust ultimately drives every marketplace’s margin to zero — the ironic endpoint being that a perfectly efficient economy, the very thing capitalism optimizes toward, actually destroys capitalism’s ability to generate profit at all.

Key points

  • Amazon has blocked Meta's new agent, Muse, from operating on its platform in just its second week.
  • Brit: Amazon's motives are twofold — protecting its own in-house shopping agent and defending a massive advertising business from disintermediation.
  • Dave argues platform blocking is ultimately futile against open-source, locally-run agents like OpenClaw, predicting the dynamic will shift to case-by-case business-development deals, similar to AdWords-era arrangements.
  • Sam has already given Claude full control of a Mac Mini and frames bot-detection as a permanent 'war of attrition' between agents mimicking human behavior and platforms trying to catch them.
  • Dave's favorite story of the week: the first thing people do with new agents is mass-unsubscribe from email lists; Brit already has her agent summarizing her information emails and wants to filter Amazon listings to American-only brands.
  • Sam says his real bottleneck with Muse/Grok isn't quality but throughput: he spends roughly $2,000/month on CPU because he wants many parallel computers, not one fast one, and would pay far more for that.
  • Sam's closing thesis: a perfectly efficient, frictionless agent economy with no platform loyalty eventually drives marketplace margins to zero — ironically, a perfectly efficient economy destroys capitalism's ability to generate profit.

Where they landed

JessicaFrames blocking skirmishes as a normal, early feature of big-tech platform launches rather than a decisive signal.
BritSees Amazon's block as rational self-defense of its own agent and ad business; wants her own agent working harder on her behalf regardless.
DaveBlocking is a losing long-term strategy against open-source, user-run agents; expect negotiated business deals instead.
SamThe real constraint is compute throughput, not capability, and a frictionless agent economy ultimately erodes the profit margins that make markets worth running.

Quotes

“We're in like week two of Muse, and an interesting development is that Amazon has blocked Muse, right?”— Jessica
“By the way, just use an open claw, and nobody can block you.”— Dave
“My biggest issue with Muse and Grokbot... is like I spend two thousand dollars a month, not on GPU, but on CPU at this point.”— Sam
“If we all are using open claws on local machines and never thinking about any service and have no relationship to any marketplace and no trust, they're all going to zero... the irony is that a perfectly efficient economy destroys capitalism.”— Sam

Suggested tweets

Amazon just blocked Meta's new agent Muse from shopping on its platform — in week two. Brit Morin: it's protecting its own agent and its ad business. Dave Morin: good luck blocking open source.

Tweet this →

Sam Lessin's real complaint about AI agents isn't quality, it's throughput: he's spending $2,000 a month on CPU because he wants a ton of parallel computers, not one fast one.

Tweet this →

Sam Lessin's sharpest line of the episode: "A perfectly efficient economy destroys capitalism." If agents kill brand loyalty and price-shop everything instantly, margins go to zero.

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #168 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify