More or Less · Topics · Episode #169

AI Is Communist: Adrian's Moats and Sam's Middle Ages 2.0

Clip from the full recording, 57:12–61:47 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Adrian's parting thought is that AI commoditizes value instantly, so where do real businesses survive; Sam answers with a dark vision of castle-and-moat hoarding and closed, no-cold-pitch society.

For his parting word Adrian says AI moves so fast that value created by a new agent collapses as soon as an idea is out, because anyone can build anything. He lists what might survive: infrastructure like energy and GPUs, proprietary data (the Jane Street model), and secret algorithms, noting that everyone copied a recent classifier algorithm within 48 hours. He suggests a shift to physical products or more secrecy. Sam jokes that AI is communist and Adrian says he’d have said commoditized.

Sam says the other negative future is Middle Ages 2.0: everyone builds a castle and moat and hoards. Closed black-box sovereigns that you can’t open or edit, a car that self-destructs if you touch it, because there’s no other way to create moats. Dave says that future isn’t here and the world is still open; Sam says it only needs a crash, and cites VC cold pitches as proof: AI makes them too easy to generate, so you lock down and only talk to your friends. Jess says news already experienced this.

Dave objects that it’s too fear-based and not how humans are, and Sam says it’s still more practical than the 10 percent kill-all-people scenario.

Key points

  • Adrian: AI is a commodity that can build anything, so any new agent idea collapses in value almost immediately.
  • Adrian's moat candidates: infrastructure (energy, GPUs), proprietary data like Jane Street's, and secret algorithms.
  • Adrian: a recent classifier algorithm was copied by everyone within about 48 hours; maybe companies should sell physical outputs or be more secretive.
  • Sam: the dark future is Middle Ages 2.0, where everyone builds a castle and moat and hoards black-box systems.
  • Sam: VCs can't take cold pitches anymore because AI makes them too easy to generate, so people lock down and only talk to friends.
  • Dave: that future is too fear-based and not how humans are by default; Sam says it's more practical than the 10 percent kill-all-people scenario.

Where they landed

AdrianThe things worth building are infrastructure, proprietary data and secret algorithms.
SamMoats only come from hoarding; AI could create a closed, stratified society, which is a practical concern.
DaveThat closed future is too negative and isn't here; we're decidedly in the open version.
JessicaThe news industry already lived through this; calls it a pendulum.

Quotes

“because AI is this kind of cool commodity that can go build anything, as soon as the idea comes out, everyone does it and we collapse that value like immediately, right?”— Adrian
“kind of like the Middle Ages version where everyone effectively builds a castle in a moat and hoards.”— Sam
“it's very hard to take cold pitches as a VC now because you're inundated with them. It's too easy to generate reasonably credible things. So what do you do? You lock down and only talk to your friends, right?”— Sam
“this is my like scoffing at the 10% kill all people thing.”— Sam

Suggested tweets

Adrian Aoun's parting thought: AI is a cool commodity that can build anything, so "as soon as the idea comes out, everyone does it and we collapse that value like immediately." Where do you build a real business?

Tweet this →

Sam Lessin's dark AI future: "the Middle Ages version where everyone effectively builds a castle in a moat and hoards." Black-box cars that self-destruct if you touch them.

Tweet this →

Sam on AI and cold pitches: "It's too easy to generate reasonably credible things. So what do you do? You lock down and only talk to your friends."

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #169 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify