More or Less · Topics · Episode #170
Selling Pro Rata: Sam on Megalith, Seed Funds, and LPs Who Resent GPs Making Money
Clip from the full recording, 44:38–51:03 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube
Brit introduces Megalith, a vehicle buying seed funds' pro rata rights; Sam and Dave explain why those rights are fragile and why LPs behave the way they do.
Brit describes Megalith (Michael Romano’s new vehicle), which buys pro rata rights from seed funds that often can’t exercise them: no dry powder, no follow-on mandate, or not organized for it. Sam’s first reaction is that it’s insane but kind of funny. Dave says the LP ecosystem doesn’t want to pay for this right now.
Sam notes Slow always writes pro rata rights into seed deals and tells founders explicitly, because later-stage funds will tell you your seed pro rata doesn’t matter and try to quash it. It happened early in Slow’s history with a well-known large VC that was an LP of theirs. Dave says since then he assumes mega Series A funds renegotiate and take pro rata from everyone, and the only protection is a great founder relationship; Sam adds, or a willingness to go nuclear. Without follow-on, he says, seed math is hard in capital-consumptive times unless you’re in crypto.
Brit says Megalith lets GPs keep most of the carry and takes about a 1.25% slice. Dave calls it buying private-market beta, second pickings. Sam says as an LP he’d want the fund to offer the deal to him as an SPV first. Brit says about 64% of LPs now want co-invest rights, with no fee and tiny carry. Sam then describes two kinds of LPs: those happy when their GPs make money, and those personally affronted by it. And he says private markets are the treaty markets: “treaties, not standards” is the newsletter theme.
Key points
- Brit: Megalith buys pro rata rights from seed funds that lack dry powder or follow-on mandates.
- Sam: Slow writes pro rata into every seed deal and will never fold on it; later-stage funds often quash seed pro rata.
- Dave: mega Series A funds renegotiate and take pro rata from everyone; only a founder relationship protects you.
- Sam: another defense is a willingness to go nuclear; seed math without follow-on is very hard.
- Brit: Megalith takes roughly a 1.25% slice of carry; about 64% of LPs now want co-invest rights.
- Sam: some LPs love when GPs make money; others are personally affronted by it. Private markets are treaty markets.
Where they landed
Quotes
“Some people, later stage funds, are gonna tell you later that your seed pro router doesn't matter”— Sam
“the big mega Series A funds, will just take away pro rata from everyone.”— Dave
“it's an insult to them for the GPs to make money”— Sam
“it's treaties, not standards.”— Sam
Suggested tweets
Megalith buys pro rata rights from seed funds. Sam: Slow always papers pro rata and never folds, because later-stage funds will say it doesn't matter. Dave: Series A megafunds take it from everyone.
Tweet this →Sam on LPs: some are thrilled when GPs make money; others seem "personally affronted if GPs make money." Brit: 64% of LPs now want co-invest rights, with no fee and tiny carry.
Tweet this →Sam on private markets: "it's treaties, not standards." Pro rata, co-invest, SPVs. The newsletter theme of the week?
Tweet this →All topics · Full episode #170 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify