More or Less · Topics · Episode #172
Sam's Real Theory: The Merger Timing Is About Diluting Elon's Stock-Lockup Cliff
Clip from the full recording, 24:01–27:36 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube
Sam floats a hot-off-the-press theory nobody else has said yet: merging now dilutes the share count right before a massive SpaceX stock-lockup cliff hits next spring, making the supply shock easier to absorb -- though Dave notes Musk doesn't actually control the outcome.
Sam offers a theory he says he just came up with live: SpaceX is facing “massive fucking unlocks” next spring as private-market investors who’ve been locked up for years become free to sell. If the denominator of ownership stays just SpaceX, that cliff could represent 50-80% of the company’s value hitting the market at once. But if SpaceX and Tesla are already merged, that same locked-up stock becomes a much smaller slice – maybe 30% – of a combined, larger company, which Sam argues is “an easier pill to swallow” from a pure supply-and-demand standpoint. He notes roughly half, maybe 60%, of his own SpaceX stock is currently locked up, giving him a direct personal stake in how this plays out.
Jessica adds that the merger narrative has real substance beyond stock mechanics: SpaceX’s data-center ambitions and Terrafab’s silicon manufacturing business both plausibly fit under one roof with Tesla. But Dave complicates the inevitability of it all with a detail from the earnings call itself: Musk said he has no actual control over the outcome, since it requires over 50% of Tesla’s shareholders to vote yes – a genuinely high bar.
Jessica closes the loop by comparing this to Musk’s Twitter acquisition: messy, controversial, and not on his preferred timeline, but ultimately he got it done – just as he eventually got his contested pay package through.
Key points
- Sam's theory, floated live and described as his own hot-off-the-press idea: merging now dilutes the share count right before a massive SpaceX stock-lockup cliff hits next spring, cushioning the supply shock.
- Roughly half, maybe up to 60%, of Sam's own SpaceX stock is currently locked up, giving him a personal stake in the mechanics.
- Jessica adds that SpaceX's data-center ambitions and Terrafab's silicon manufacturing business give the combined-company narrative real substance beyond pure stock mechanics.
- Dave reveals Musk said on the earnings call that he has no actual control over the outcome -- the merger requires over 50% of Tesla's shareholders to approve it.
- Jessica compares it to Musk's Twitter acquisition: controversial and off his preferred timeline, but he ultimately got it done -- just like his contested pay package.
Where they landed
Quotes
“SpaceX's thing this spring, in about six months, is gonna be massive fucking unlocks.”— Sam
“If the enormous cliff, instead of being 80% of the value of all of SpaceX, is instead 30% of the value of SpaceX plus Tesla, that is gonna be an easier pill to swallow from a supply and demand perspective.”— Sam
“He was like, look, I think we should do this, but I don't have any control over the outcome -- over 50% of Tesla shareholders have to vote for this.”— Dave
“When Elon sets his sight on a deal, it usually happens. It doesn't necessarily happen without controversy.”— Jessica
Suggested tweets
Sam Lessin's hot-off-the-press theory on the real reason for the SpaceX-Tesla merger timing: it dilutes the denominator right before a massive SpaceX stock-lockup cliff hits next spring. 'That is gonna be an easier pill to swallow.'
Tweet this →Sam Lessin says roughly half -- maybe 60% -- of his own SpaceX stock is currently locked up. His merger theory has a personal stake behind it.
Tweet this →Dave Morin: Musk himself said on the earnings call that the SpaceX-Tesla merger isn't guaranteed -- it needs over 50% of Tesla shareholders to vote yes. 'That's a really tall order.'
Tweet this →All topics · Full episode #172 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify