More or Less · Topics · Episode #173
Farmville, Then Amazon, Then ChatGPT: When Do Products Cross the Line Into Gaming Their Users?
Clip from the full recording, 26:50–32:59 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube
Dave asks Bing the question the episode is named for — when does engagement design tip into gaming people against their own interest — using Farmville's quiet collapse in NPS as the cautionary tale, and landing on Amazon's sponsored listings and ChatGPT's endless follow-up question as today's version.
Dave recalls Bing’s own book anecdote: Farmville players felt relief after quitting, even while the game’s retention and revenue numbers kept climbing. Bing’s answer leans on Bezos’s dictum that when anecdotes and data disagree, trust the anecdotes — and the real tell at Zynga was that players’ NPS and willingness to refer the game both cratered the moment they quit, something Bing had never seen before. His diagnosis: Farmville had “too much pinch” — freemium flipped the old caveat-emptor logic into “vendor beware,” extracting engagement the post-hoc NPS score said people didn’t actually want to give.
Bing credits Reed Hoffman with the clearest framing: growth hacking is like human growth hormone — fine in a short, intentional pulse (training for the Tour de France), dangerous as a sustained habit, where you eventually have to reckon with the “cancer risk.” Asked whether today’s successful products have the same problem, Bing points to anything people call doom-scrolling (probably TikTok), contrasts it with WhatsApp (which he credits Zuck with protecting, partly because it has no engagement timeline to exploit), and offers his own long-running personal metric: if he’s glad he saw less than 30% of a publication’s content, he unsubscribes. He flags Amazon’s pre-recommendation ads and Google’s incentive to show users what’s good for Google over what’s good for them as the current version of the same risk, and traces Twitter’s decline to the moment clicks became the product — handing control to middle managers whose promotions depended on ad sales, which he links to the Cambridge Analytica-era propaganda problem.
Brit closes the loop by pointing out her own Amazon Prime subscription still shows sponsored products despite the subscription fee, and extends the pattern straight into the AI era: ChatGPT ends nearly every answer with some version of “would you like to do this?” — the same engagement hook Bing has been describing all along, just wearing a new coat.
Key points
- Farmville's players' NPS and willingness to refer the game both cratered the moment they quit — even as revenue and retention metrics kept climbing, which is Bing's working definition of "too much pinch."
- Bing's touchstone: Bezos's rule that when the anecdotes and the data disagree, trust the anecdotes.
- Reed Hoffman's framing, as Bing retells it: growth hacking is like human growth hormone — a short, intentional pulse is fine, sustained use eventually carries a "cancer risk."
- Bing's own long-running personal metric for a publication: if he's glad he saw less than 30% of its content, he unsubscribes.
- WhatsApp has stayed comparatively unexploited, per Bing, partly because Zuck protected it and partly because it has no engagement timeline to monetize against.
- Bing traces Twitter's decline to the moment clicks became the product, handing influence to middle managers whose promotions depended on ad sales — which he links to the Cambridge Analytica-era propaganda problem.
- Brit's closing parallel: her Amazon Prime subscription still shows sponsored listings, and ChatGPT's habit of ending every answer with "would you like to do this?" is the same engagement hook in AI form.
Where they landed
Quotes
“Bezos always says when the anecdotes and the data don't agree, trust the anecdotes.”— Bing
“I think Farmville was an example of too much pinch.”— Bing
“Growth hacking is great for a really short time, you know, it's kind of like human growth hormone — if you get addicted to it, at least you know your cancer risk every now and then.”— Bing
“My prime subscription doesn't remove sponsored products from Amazon. So I'm getting double hit... ChatGPT always ends with a question, you know. Here's the answer. Now would you like to do this? Now would you like to do this?”— Brit
Suggested tweets
Bing Gordon on Farmville: players' NPS and referrals cratered the moment they quit — even as revenue and retention numbers kept climbing. His term for it: "too much pinch."
Tweet this →Reed Hoffman's line, via Bing Gordon: growth hacking is like human growth hormone — great for a short time, but if you get addicted, eventually you have to reckon with the cancer risk.
Tweet this →Brit Morin's gripe: her Amazon Prime subscription still shows sponsored products. Her bigger point — ChatGPT ending every answer with "would you like to do this?" is the same hook, just wearing a new coat.
Tweet this →All topics · Full episode #173 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify