More or Less · Topics · Episode #173
'Menu Toys': Why a Great UI Can Make Engineering Look Better Than It Is
Clip from the full recording, 57:54–62:03 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube
Bing's 'invest and express' principle — even a simple like is a contribution people stay loyal for — runs from Twitch's emergent chat culture to his term for great design, 'menu toys,' and a Bingism Dave Morin still uses at every board meeting he sits in.
Bing’s “invest and express” principle holds that people are more engaged and more loyal the moment they contribute something, even something as small as a like — any signal sent back to the server counts. His proof point is Twitch: once someone chats and gets a response, they’re on the path to becoming a loyal, paying subscriber to that streamer, and crucially, that chat culture emerged organically rather than being deliberately engineered by the company. The same logic applies to what’s literally on the wall at home or school — messy kid-made art tells a child their contribution matters as much as anyone else’s, more than a store-bought poster of Einstein ever could.
From there Bing coins a term for design itself: “menu toys.” A genuinely great UI, he argues, convinces people the underlying engineering is better than it actually is — the same function a gilt frame serves for the Mona Lisa, which would look unremarkable found loose in a flea market. Dave picks up the thread with a specific memory from building Path: Bing used to make him hold the product up and view it from across the room, over someone’s shoulder, on the theory that a stranger walking down an airplane aisle should be able to instantly recognize whose app that is. Dave still uses the test in board meetings today, including one two weeks before this recording, where he found himself asking a founder’s team, “which color is our color?”
The segment closes on a broader communication lesson Bing says underlies all of it: when you’re right and want to actually be heard, you often need to back up first — give the anecdote and the context before the conclusion — rather than stating the hard truth cold and watching people shut down.
Key points
- Bing's "invest and express" principle: people are more engaged and loyal the moment they contribute something, even a simple like counts as a server-side signal.
- Twitch's chat culture wasn't deliberately engineered by the company — it emerged organically, and once a viewer chats and gets a response, they're on the path to becoming a loyal subscriber.
- What's literally on the wall (messy kid art vs. a store-bought poster) signals to a child whether their own contribution matters as much as anyone else's.
- Bing's term "menu toys": a great UI convinces people the underlying engineering is better than it actually is — the same function the Mona Lisa's gilt frame serves.
- Dave Morin's "Bingism" from building Path: judge a UI by whether a total stranger glancing over your shoulder on a plane would instantly recognize the brand's color.
- Dave says he still uses that test in board meetings today, including one two weeks before this recording where a founder's own team couldn't agree on "which color is our color."
- Bing's broader communication rule: when you're right and want to be heard, back up and give context/anecdote first rather than stating the hard conclusion cold.
Where they landed
Quotes
“Once people chat and get responded to, they're on a path to becoming a subscriber and loyal to a streamer... the miracle of Twitch is this community chat that wasn't really engineered by the company.”— Bing
“A great UI can convince people that the engineering's a lot better. By the way, a great UI is that gilt frame around Mona Lisa.”— Bing
“I remember you used to come into Path and make me show you the UI from like over my shoulder from far away... can you tell like if somebody's on an airplane just walking by, can they tell that that's our color?”— Dave
“When you're right and you want to be heard, sometimes you need to back up.”— Bing
Suggested tweets
Bing Gordon's theory of Twitch's success: the community chat culture wasn't engineered by the company at all — it was pure emergent behavior, and it's the real driver of subscriber loyalty.
Tweet this →Bing Gordon calls it "menu toys": a great UI can convince people the engineering underneath is way better than it is. His example — the gilt frame around the Mona Lisa.
Tweet this →Dave Morin still uses a trick Bing Gordon taught him at Path: judge a UI by whether a total stranger glancing over your shoulder on a plane would instantly recognize it.
Tweet this →All topics · Full episode #173 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify