More or Less · Topics · Episode #169

Is This the End of Times or the Beginning? "Her" vs the Disembodiment of Humans

Clip from the full recording, 41:43–46:06 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Dave offers the optimist case that we can finally speak English to computers and get off screens, while Adrian argues the opposite thesis: technology lets us escape our bodies and we'll get used to it.

Dave reframes the angst: for thirty years people sat in buildings staring at glowing rectangles and fidgeting with computers, and the output wasn’t great. Now we can just speak English to computers and be creative, and the movie people cite as the future they want is Her. Sam and Jess object that Her is dystopian and the lead is lonely, but Dave says what people really want from it is the screen-free home and more offline time with friends.

Adrian takes an almost opposite view: the disembodiment of humans. As a kid with a thick accent, he felt more genuine online, where he could be any height and had no accent. His claim is that early agent-to-agent communication feels dystopian, but products only get adopted if consumers want them and they become better at tricking you into believing it’s what you want, and we get accustomed to them. Imagine telling someone in 1950 we’d all stare at four-inch glass rectangles.

Jess says human agency is the key and she feels less of a slave to her phone. Dave says it might be the beginning of times and that computers are the thing that wastes time.

Key points

  • Dave: people have spent thirty years fidgeting with computers; speaking English to them is the exciting break from that era.
  • Dave: people cite Her as the future they want; they want a screen-free home and more offline time.
  • Sam and Jess: Her is dystopian and the lead is lonely.
  • Adrian's thesis is the disembodiment of humans: tech lets people express who they wanted to be, as the internet did for him as an awkward kid.
  • Adrian: agents will feel dystopian first, then consumers get tricked into wanting them and the Overton window moves, as with phones since 1950.
  • Jess: human agency is the key variable; she feels less of a slave to her phone.

Where they landed

DaveOptimist: speaking English to computers frees us from screens and gives us more time offline with friends.
AdrianDisembodiment thesis: we'll use tech to express ourselves and will get used to living through screens and agents.
JessicaHuman agency matters; she feels less enslaved to her phone.
SamCalls Her a cynical movie about a lonely man; says it may be both.
BritSkeptical that everyone benefits.

Quotes

“Maybe it is not the end of times. Maybe it's the beginning of times.”— Dave
“people spent the majority of their days. Sitting in buildings, looking at glowing rectangles, fidgeting with computers to try to get them to do the things that they wanted them to do.”— Dave
“It's a very cynical movie.”— Sam
“I have like almost the exact opposite thesis, which is what I think of as like the disembodiment of humans.”— Adrian
“Ergo, products have to be better and better at kind of tricking you into believing this is what you want.”— Adrian

Suggested tweets

Dave Morin: "Maybe it is not the end of times. Maybe it's the beginning of times." For 30 years we sat staring at glowing rectangles. Now we can just speak English to computers.

Tweet this →

Adrian Aoun's opposite thesis: "the disembodiment of humans." Tech lets you be the version of yourself you couldn't be in real life, and agent-to-agent talk feels dystopian only until the Overton window moves.

Tweet this →

Sam on the movie Her: "It's a very cynical movie." Dave says people want the screen-free home it depicts. Is the agent era the end of times or the beginning?

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #169 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify