More or Less · Topics · Episode #169

Sam: There's No Moat, Switching Is Free, and the Idiot (Apple) Wins

Clip from the full recording, 38:17–41:42 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Sam's three points: bots can print your daily report, switching costs are zero, and the only lock-in is BD, while Dave says no one agent wins and the group agrees Instinct won't be independent in 18 months.

Sam makes three short points. First, Jess’s idea of giving the bots the printer so she doesn’t have to stare at screens is brilliant, and the printer is now humming with daily reports. Second, there is no moat from switching: he keeps a GitHub repo of databases, and when Muse came online he just fed it everything Claude had built for him. It’s costless to switch, and always will be. Third, the only path to lock-in is BD, which would mean business teams getting overpaid to cut exclusivity deals the way engineers and political operatives were.

Jess says exclusivity won’t last; the Microsoft-OpenAI marriage lasted about a year. Adrian adds vertical integration, like an iPhone hoarding what it hears. Brit says Apple and Google should be winning this, Jess complains Siri couldn’t call her design chief, and Sam says that’s why it will be hilarious when the idiot wins.

Dave says nobody wins: the future is polyagentamorous, everyone talks to every agent, and Instinct did 1 billion in GMV, half in travel, making it the new Kayak. Sam shrugs at the number. Jess asks for a show of hands on whether Instinct is independent in 18 months, and nobody raises one.

Key points

  • Sam: giving the bots the printer so you don't stare at screens is a brilliant idea; his printer now prints daily reports.
  • Sam: there is no switching cost; he fed Muse everything Claude had built for him at no cost, and always will be able to.
  • Sam: the only possible lock-in is BD, which would reward business teams the way engineers and political operatives have been rewarded.
  • Jess: exclusivity won't last; Microsoft-OpenAI's marriage lasted roughly a year.
  • Brit and Sam: Apple and Google should win this, and it would be hilarious if the idiot wins.
  • Dave: there will be no one agent to rule them all; the future is polyagentamorous, and Instinct is the new Kayak with 1 billion GMV, half of it travel.
  • Jess's poll: nobody thinks Instinct is an independent company in 18 months.

Where they landed

SamNo switching cost and no moat; only BD-driven lock-in is possible; Apple winning would be the funniest outcome.
AdrianVertical integration is a possible moat, and BD exclusivity won't happen.
JessicaExclusivity deals fade quickly; Siri is terrible; no one thinks Instinct stays independent.
BritApple and Google should be winning this.
DaveNobody wins outright; Instinct's GMV is mostly travel.

Quotes

“I literally just fed it everything that Claude had built for me, and like there's no switching cost, right? And there never will be”— Sam
“The only way there ends up being lock-in, somehow, right, is through BD, which is hilarious.”— Sam
“when the idiot wins, that's gonna be the funniest fucking outcome.”— Sam
“there will not be one agent to rule them all. Like the future is polyagentiamorous.”— Dave
“Instinct did 1 billion in GMV and 50% of it is travel.”— Dave

Suggested tweets

Sam Lessin: "I literally just fed it everything that Claude had built for me, and there's no switching cost. And there never will be." Adrian's moat question gets a blunt answer.

Tweet this →

Sam on how AI lock-in could actually happen: "The only way... is through BD, which is hilarious." Business teams are the next group to get overpaid.

Tweet this →

Dave Morin says no agent wins: "the future is polyagentamorous." Instinct did $1B in GMV, half of it travel. Jess polls the group: nobody thinks Instinct is independent in 18 months.

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #169 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify