More or Less · Topics · Episode #169

OpenAI Rebrands Codex as Dots, and Adrian Asks the Question: What's the Moat?

Clip from the full recording, 31:09–37:57 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Dots is Muse and Instinct from OpenAI, Dave says it's still 1982, Adrian wants to know what Instinct's moat is, and Brit realizes her agent now texts her husband's agent instead of her husband.

Dave explains that OpenAI rebranded Codex as Dots because normal people don’t know how to use Codex and moms don’t want something called Codex. Adrian says everyone has the same functionality, just packaged differently, and that Instinct and Muse won by going back to a single-thread assistant while Codex served power users. For existing users it feels bolted on, but with a billion-ish ChatGPT users and billions more not yet on the platform, it’s a good acquisition play. Brit notes OpenAI shipped it in a hurry, within a month of Grokbot, Instinct and Muse. Dave says it’s 1982 and the Macintosh hasn’t been invented yet.

Adrian then asks what really matters: if Instinct is worth eight quadrillion dollars, what’s the moat? Sam says: what if there is none? Adrian argues that if software cost goes to zero there’s no moat on integrations unless they’re built via BD deals, though setup cost will produce winner-take-some. Brit describes Instinct agents talking to each other, loved by moms for coordination, but warns she stopped texting Dave because their agents did it, which she thinks has serious social repercussions.

Adrian counters that FaceTime friendships are fine, so agents are just an Overton-window shift. Brit and Jess disagree: there’s no humanity in it, and Jess plans to cut her screen time 20 percent with bots.

Key points

  • Dave: OpenAI rebranded Codex as Dots because Codex is for coders and moms won't use it.
  • Adrian: every agent has the same functionality; Instinct and Muse won on a single-thread assistant UX while Codex served power users.
  • Brit: OpenAI shipped this in a hurry, within a month of Grokbot, Instinct and Muse.
  • Dave: it's 1982 and nobody has figured out how to make agents useful for everyone at global scale.
  • Adrian: the real question is the moat; with software cost going to zero, integrations don't protect anyone unless locked in by BD deals.
  • Brit: agent-to-agent coordination is loved by moms but she stopped texting Dave because their agents did it.
  • Adrian: FaceTime already mediates friendship, so agent-mediated communication is an Overton-window shift.

Where they landed

DaveIt's 1982 for agents; Dots is OpenAI's rebrand for normal people.
AdrianEveryone has the same capabilities; the only question is the moat, and communicating through agents will become normal.
BritAgent-to-agent coordination works but hollows out human contact.
SamAsks what if there is no moat at all.
JessicaDisagrees that agent mediation is like FaceTime and plans to cut screen time 20 percent.

Quotes

“It's nineteen eighty-two. The Macintosh hasn't been invented yet. Nobody has figured out how to make AI agents useful for the every person at global scale.”— Dave
“So if Instinct is worth eight quadrillion dollars or whatever it's worth right now, I wanna know what's the moat.”— Adrian
“What if there is none?”— Sam
“I did it with Dave, and then I didn't even text with Dave for a whole day. And I was just like, dave, text my agent.”— Brit
“Like, why is FaceTime okay, but my instinct agent is not okay?”— Adrian

Suggested tweets

Adrian Aoun: "If Instinct is worth eight quadrillion dollars or whatever it's worth right now, I wanna know what's the moat." Sam's answer: "What if there is none?"

Tweet this →

Dave Morin on agents: "It's 1982. The Macintosh hasn't been invented yet." OpenAI rebrands Codex as Dots because moms won't use something called Codex.

Tweet this →

Brit Morin's agent started coordinating with Dave's agent, and now she doesn't text Dave at all. "I'm losing actual context of humans." Adrian: why is FaceTime okay but this isn't?

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #169 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify