More or Less · Topics · Episode #170
Building Agents vs. Building Agency, and Why Brands Will Eventually Fold
Clip from the full recording, 31:24–37:58 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube
Dave asks whose potential the AI valuations underwrite while companies block users' own agents; Sam says capitalism tends to zero profit; Brit bets most brands will fold like they did for Instagram.
Dave reframes the fight as Hilton versus an AI company for control of the customer, and asks where the human’s agency is. An agent that works for you is different from another platform inserting itself in your life. He says human potential isn’t just productivity but the ability to act on your own intentions, and he separates building agents from building agency, a phrase from an OpenClaw meeting that morning. If a user has real power and sends a tool to act for them, they should be able to, and company incentives are a messy smokescreen around that.
Sam compares it to the old fight over who owns your data. Europe’s download-your-data rule was the saving grace, while the right to be forgotten is, he says, the dumbest law ever written. Now it’s inverted: a company’s whole value is its customer relationship, and once you’re a commodity in a market you’re worthless. He calls it the wild part of capitalism: it pushes everyone to invent and meet the market, but it tends toward zero profit, so Hilton has to innovate rather than rely on the relationship.
Brit recalls brands that held back from Instagram and YouTube. Sam says they saw the game but faced a collective action problem; a thousand others would fill any hole. Brit adds that audiences were on social media anyway and Google sponsored ads already diverted traffic, so agents can’t be refused: her bet is that most brands fold, with Hilton and Amazon as holdouts, and she cites McKinsey’s three-to-five trillion dollar market by 2030 and ChatGPT’s 50 million daily shopping queries.
Key points
- Dave: build agents versus agency; a user's own agent should be able to act on their intentions.
- Dave: company incentives (renting agents, ads, commercial deals) form a messy smokescreen around what users want.
- Sam: Europe's download-your-data mandate was a saving grace; the right to be forgotten is the dumbest law ever written.
- Sam: capitalism tends toward zero profit; a company whose relationship collapses to zero becomes a commodity and must innovate.
- Sam: brands failed to resist Instagram because of a collective action problem; any hole would be filled.
- Brit: majority of brands will fold; McKinsey projects a $3-5T market by 2030 and ChatGPT already sees about 50M shopping queries per day.
Where they landed
Quotes
“I kind of think about building agents versus building agency”— Dave
“The right to be forgotten is the dumbest law ever written.”— Sam
“It was a collective action problem, which was that they couldn't gang up and together like hold the line of being like no.”— Sam
“my bet is that over time, majority of these brands fold and let agents buy stuff from them, book stuff from them.”— Brit
Suggested tweets
Dave: "I kind of think about building agents versus building agency." Are we building a new intermediary or giving the individual more power? Whose potential are we underwriting?
Tweet this →Sam on EU data law: download-your-data is the saving grace, "The right to be forgotten is the dumbest law ever written." Same fight, inverted, now it's brands vs. your agent.
Tweet this →Brit: "my bet is that over time, majority of these brands fold." Sam: brands didn't fail Instagram from ignorance, it was "a collective action problem."
Tweet this →All topics · Full episode #170 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify