More or Less · Topics · Episode #170

If You're Hilton's CEO: Collective Action, Collusion and Why Facebook Connect Failed

Clip from the full recording, 28:00–31:24 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Brit asks what Hilton's CEO should do about bots; Sam says hotels face a collective action problem, then ties agent identity to the failure of Facebook Connect and Open Graph, which lacked a value trade for brands.

Brit asks Sam to play Hilton’s CEO. Sam says the answer depends on incentives: a hired-gun CEO who cares only about the next three years may want volume at all costs and let bots book anything, while a steward of capital wants to keep the customer relationship. It’s also a legal puzzle, because if all hoteliers agreed to refuse bots for the sake of the human relationship, that could look like collusion. Will the tech companies and bots exploit the collective action problem for short-term volume, he asks, or will industries find a way to push back?

Brit says that’s why a personal agent protocol is emerging; Josh Elman compared it to Facebook Connect, where an authorized identity means you should be able to buy anything at Walmart through your agent. Sam says he has a half-written essay on this: Facebook Connect and Open Graph failed and had to be shut down for the same reason, not enough value exchange for brands. What worked in Dave’s platform era was feed distribution in exchange for data. After that, no one found a clear business case for why brands should give data, and Sam was the one who had to say fine, we’re done.

Brit cites early data that agent commerce increases spending and speeds checkout. Sam agrees it will drive volume in the short run, and says his Muse agent booked a car service flawlessly the other day, but asks at what cost: if we truly live in a world of agentic efficiency, no one makes any money. Brit’s answer is that brands have to be stronger than ever. Sam describes his Hilton test, asking for an LAX hotel for an early flight without caring which one, which is exactly the efficient market Hilton fears.

Key points

  • Sam: the Hilton CEO's choice depends on whether they're a three-year hired gun maximizing volume or a steward who needs the customer relationship.
  • Sam: if hotels collectively refused bots it could look like collusion, but acting alone they face a classic collective action problem.
  • Brit/Josh Elman: a verified personal agent protocol resembles Facebook Connect, bringing your identity along.
  • Sam: Facebook Connect and Open Graph failed for lack of a value trade for brands; only feed distribution for data ever worked, and he had to shut platform down.
  • Brit: early e-commerce data shows agents lift spend and speed up checkout.
  • Sam: short-term volume is real, but in a world of agentic efficiency "no one's gonna make any money."

Where they landed

SamAgentic commerce is a collective action trap that tends toward efficient, low-profit markets; Facebook Connect failed for the same lack of value exchange.
BritArgues agent protocols can authorize identity and that the early commerce metrics are positive; brands must be stronger.
DaveMostly listening here.

Quotes

“it's a really interesting collective action problem”— Sam
“there was never a clear business case for why”— Sam
“if we actually live in a world of agentic efficiency, no one's gonna make any money,”— Sam

Suggested tweets

Sam on Hilton vs. the bots: if hotels all say no to agents "that's like collusion." Otherwise it's a classic collective action problem. Short-term volume, long-term "no one's gonna make any money."

Tweet this →

Sam: Facebook Connect and Open Graph failed because there was no value exchange for brands. Feed distribution for data worked once. After that, "there was never a clear business case."

Tweet this →

Brit: agent shoppers spend more and check out faster. Sam: sure, short term. "If we actually live in a world of agentic efficiency, no one's gonna make any money."

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #170 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify