More or Less · Topics · Episode #170

Sam on Agent Standards: "It's All Bullshit," and His Muse Bot Hits Hilton's Bot Wall

Clip from the full recording, 23:07–28:00 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Brit introduces a Meta, Walmart, Shopify, Stripe and Sierra effort to publish an agent-commerce standard. Sam says standards don't matter because everything is just an API, and that Hilton's website is already stonewalling bots.

Brit brings up the week’s news: Meta, Walmart, Shopify, Sierra, Stripe and others are trying to publish a standard for how AI agents transact on your behalf, with an audit trail. Dave says the standard isn’t about protecting anyone, it’s about making commerce happen. Sam says it’s the old open-versus-closed fight, and that the internet was born with no identity layer so anything could interact with anything, which is both why it grew and why we have spam.

Then he confesses he still doesn’t understand why anyone cares about MCP: everything is just an API, and AI can read API documentation or even reverse-engineer an undocumented one. Either a service is reachable by machines and will be used by machines, or it’s protected. So the standards and protocols are, in his words, all bullshit. What does matter is that workflows that used to work are being turned off.

His example: last-minute hotel booking the night before, his Muse agent got stuck in a doom loop on Hilton’s site, almost certainly anti-bot defenses. After the third retry he booked it himself. Businesses are correctly realizing that if you become one more way to clear a transaction at the back end, the market becomes too efficient and your business is worthless. Sam’s framing: this isn’t a technical problem, bots can already do commerce. It’s business and politics, as it was with Open Graph.

Key points

  • Brit: Meta, Walmart, Instinct, Shopify, Sierra and Stripe are working on a standard for how AI agents transact, with an audit trail.
  • Dave: the standard is about making commerce happen, not about protecting anyone.
  • Sam: the internet launched with no identity layer, which was both its biggest weakness and why it grew.
  • Sam: he doesn't get the MCP hype; it's all an API, and machines can read or reverse-engineer APIs anyway, so standards and protocols are "all bullshit."
  • Sam: his Muse agent got stuck in a doom loop booking a Hilton room, likely due to anti-bot measures; he finished it by hand.
  • Sam: businesses understand that being intermediated into a back-end clearing step destroys their customer relationship; the real issue is business and politics, not technology.

Where they landed

SamStandards are irrelevant; machines either can access a service or can't, and businesses are already throttling bots to protect the customer relationship.
BritSees primitives like audit trails as sensible and wonders if Hilton is blocking agents.
DaveThinks the standard is mainly meant to get commerce moving and to get people talking about the problem.

Quotes

“I still don't get why anyone gives a shit about MCP.”— Sam
“these standards and protocols, is all bullshit.”— Sam
“if you get intermediated and just become yet another way to clear a transaction at the back end, like the market becomes too efficient, you'll have no relationship with the customers, and your business is worthless.”— Sam
“We don't have a technical problem.”— Sam

Suggested tweets

Sam: "I still don't get why anyone gives a shit about MCP." Everything is an API. "These standards and protocols is all bullshit." What matters is who gets to stop the bots.

Tweet this →

Sam's Muse agent got stuck in a doom loop booking a Hilton room. He gave up and booked it himself. Anti-bot walls are going up because hotels don't want to be "yet another way to clear a transaction."

Tweet this →

Sam on agentic commerce: "We don't have a technical problem." It's business and politics, same as Open Graph.

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #170 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify