More or Less · Topics · Episode #172
The Elizabeth Holmes / Nathan Fielder Film Sparks a Fight Over Whitewashing
Clip from the full recording, 47:06–51:18 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube
Sam calls the new Nathan Fielder film about Elizabeth Holmes 'possibly the best movie ever made,' Dave recounts a surprise private-screening Q&A with Holmes's husband, and Sam torches anyone online who dismisses it over an 'untrustworthy narrator.'
The group turns to a new Nathan Fielder film about Elizabeth Holmes, which Sam calls ‘possibly the best movie ever made’ and urges everyone to see. Dave recounts an extraordinary moment from a private screening hosted by Cyan Bannister: at the end, Elizabeth Holmes’s husband, Billy, was sitting in the audience, got up, walked to the front of the theater, and did an hour-long Q&A – on a night that turned out to be the first time he had ever seen the film himself.
Dave admits he previously got ‘slayed’ in The Information’s comments for expressing empathy toward Holmes as a founder who may have simply ‘fallen into the hype train’ the way many Silicon Valley figures (including, he notes, Elon) have. Sam pushes back hard on any reading of the film as whitewashing: its humanity and insight into the nature of being human doesn’t erase the fact that Holmes is on camera saying ‘absolutely batshit, straight-up lies,’ and he suspects she’s ‘probably mentally ill’ – the film being great, in his view, is not the same as the film letting her off the hook.
Sam saves his sharpest line for online critics who say they disliked the film because ‘Nathan Fielder is a totally untrustworthy narrator’ – missing, in his view, that the narrator’s unreliability is the entire point of the three-hour movie, not a flaw in it.
Key points
- The group discusses a new Nathan Fielder film about Elizabeth Holmes that Sam calls 'possibly the best movie ever made.'
- Dave recounts a Cyan Bannister-hosted private screening where Elizabeth Holmes's husband, Billy, showed up unannounced and did an hour-long Q&A -- the first time he'd seen the film himself.
- Dave admits he previously got 'slayed' in The Information's comments for expressing empathy toward Holmes as a founder who 'fell into the hype train' like many in Silicon Valley, including Elon.
- Sam pushes back hard on any 'whitewashing' read: the film's humanity doesn't excuse the fact that Holmes said 'absolutely batshit, straight-up lies' on camera and is 'probably mentally ill.'
- Sam's sharpest line is reserved for online critics who disliked the film because 'Nathan Fielder is a totally untrustworthy narrator' -- missing, in his view, that this is the entire point of the movie.
Where they landed
Quotes
“It's possibly the best movie ever made. You should definitely see it.”— Sam
“Billy, Elizabeth's husband, was sitting in the audience and just walked to the front of the theater and sat down and did an hour QA -- it was the first time he had ever seen it.”— Dave
“You lose the fact that there's hilarious videos of her saying absolutely batshit, straight-up lies.”— Sam
“You have just outed yourself as one of the dumbest people on earth. Congratulations.”— Sam
Suggested tweets
Dave Morin on a surprise screening of the new Elizabeth Holmes film: Billy, her husband, showed up unannounced, walked to the front, and did an hour-long Q&A -- the first time he'd ever seen it himself.
Tweet this →Sam Lessin's take on the new Nathan Fielder/Elizabeth Holmes film: 'Possibly the best movie ever made' -- but no, it's not whitewashing her; she's still on camera telling 'absolutely batshit, straight-up lies.'
Tweet this →Sam Lessin's review of critics who disliked the film because 'Nathan Fielder is a totally untrustworthy narrator': 'You have just outed yourself as one of the dumbest people on earth. Congratulations.'
Tweet this →All topics · Full episode #172 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify