More or Less · Topics · Episode #172

Meta's New Share Class, Mark's Control, and the Wealth-Tax Dodge Everyone Sees Coming

Clip from the full recording, 44:21–47:06 · download mp4 · watch at this point on YouTube

Meta beats earnings and quietly rolls out a new voting-stock class letting Mark Zuckerberg keep control while selling shares, which Sam reads as a hedge against a coming wealth tax -- sparking a sharper debate about whether an asset tax is now inevitable.

Meta beat earnings and stock is up, but the more interesting detail is a new class of voting stock that lets Mark Zuckerberg keep control of the company even as he sells down his own shares – a move the internet reads as self-serving rather than any kind of retreat. Sam’s theory cuts sharper: he thinks this is really about dodging a California-style wealth tax that’s calculated off voting control, a structure he says could ‘bankrupt’ founders in Google’s position, and wonders aloud whether Google’s own founders have quietly engineered something similar.

Dave, invoking Jensen Huang’s public framing, says he’s broadly sympathetic to the intent behind a wealth tax – he’s been successful and is willing to pay – but finds it ‘a terrible outcome’ that avoiding ruin now requires executives to build ‘crazy structures’ just to survive. Sam pushes the philosophical frame further with a Foucauldian argument: once wealth becomes visible and trackable the way it now is, the state will inevitably tax it, making an asset tax ‘intellectually inevitable’ even though he believes it would also be ‘a fucking disaster’ and ‘deeply un-American and unfree.’

Jessica resists being cast as pro-wealth-tax, clarifying she’s simply not anti-tax in general, while Sam reminds her she’s previously described how much paying high taxes as a new business owner genuinely stung.

Key points

  • Meta beat earnings and introduced a new voting-stock class letting Mark Zuckerberg keep control even as he sells shares; the internet reads it as self-serving.
  • Sam's theory: this is really about dodging a California-style wealth tax calculated off voting control, which he says could 'bankrupt' founders like Google's.
  • Dave, invoking Jensen Huang's framing, says he's broadly sympathetic to paying taxes on success but finds it 'a terrible outcome' that avoiding ruin requires 'crazy structures.'
  • Sam's Foucauldian counter-argument: once wealth becomes visible and trackable, the state will tax it -- an asset tax is 'intellectually inevitable' even though he thinks it would be 'deeply un-American and unfree.'
  • Jessica resists being characterized as pro-wealth-tax, clarifying she's not opposed to taxes generally even though she's previously described how much paying high taxes as a new business owner stung.

Where they landed

JessicaReports the Meta share-class news and resists Dave's framing of her own views as pro-wealth-tax.
SamSees the new stock structure as tax-motivated engineering, and believes an asset/wealth tax is functionally inevitable even though he opposes it philosophically.
DaveSympathetic to paying high taxes on success but uneasy that avoiding ruin now requires elaborate legal structuring.

Quotes

“Meta earnings beat, and stock is up. And interestingly, the implementation of a new class of voting stock so that Mark can retain control and sell his stock.”— Jessica
“Based on your voting control, you pay the wealth tax, which will bankrupt the Google co-founders.”— Sam
“I understand the intent of this wealth tax thing, and I like Jensen's perspective on it -- I've been really successful, I will pay taxes.”— Dave
“It's like this is Foucault. Once you can see something, you tax it. It seems intellectually inevitable that you end up with an asset tax, but it will also be a fucking disaster, and it's deeply un-American and unfree.”— Sam

Suggested tweets

Meta just created a new voting-stock class so Mark Zuckerberg can keep control while selling shares. Sam Lessin's theory: it's really about dodging a California-style wealth tax calculated off voting control.

Tweet this →

Sam Lessin's prediction: 'It seems intellectually inevitable that you end up with an asset tax. But it will also be a fucking disaster, and it's deeply un-American and unfree.'

Tweet this →

Dave Morin, channeling Jensen Huang, on the wealth-tax debate: 'I've been really successful, I will pay taxes' -- but he still thinks founders shouldn't need 'crazy structures' just to survive it.

Tweet this →

All topics · Full episode #172 + transcript · Subscribe on YouTube · Spotify